Turkish Rock
Tuesday, June 3rd, 2003 01:05 pmI just got Şebnem Ferah's new album, and I'm very impressed. For a long time she was in Özlem Tekin's shadow (as far as I remember, they started out in the same group, Volvox) but when Özlem got married and started doing boring electropop, Şebnem got the attention she deserved (now Özlem's on her own again and back to doing pretty decent rock music - Tek Başıma is well worth a listen). The thing I like about Şebnem's work is that it's very obviously rock, with no attempt to cash in on ethnicity, but at the same time it's still obviously Turkish (apart from the fact that she sings in Turkish, I mean). The single, Ben Şarkımı Söylerken, is a good example - at first listening it sounds like AC/DC's Thunder, but when you listen again, the Turkish modality comes out. (Did I just write "modality"?)
Anyway, this prompted me to dig out all my Turkish rock CDs, and I'm working through them. At the moment, I'm listening to Destan, which is very much folk-rock. There are some very good songs on the album, but the group never went anywhere, partly because of splits in the band, but partly, I suspect, because if half the songs on an album are credited to "anonymous", you get stuck in the folk-rock rut. In a country like Turkey which still has a very strong folk tradition, there isn't a lot of room for folk-rockers (as opposed to folk musicians who play modern instruments). Af (whose album is also lying in the pile on my sofa) were a hard rock group with a small but loyal following who experimented with folk motifs. At the time they said if was a gamble - they'd lose their hardcore fans and weren't sure if the folky elements would get them a new fanbase. As far as I can see, it didn't.
That's not to say you can't combine folk and rock elements (look at Thin Lizzy!) but, especially in a country like Turkey, you have to be very clear abouth whether you're a rock group using the traditional instruments on a few tracks or doing the occasional folk song (e.g. Pentagram) or a folk group with a bit of distorted guitar. A fifty-fifty mix doesn't seem to work.
Browsing through Amazon's Turkish music section, it's nearly all folk and Sufi music - the only popular artists to make it into the first seven pages are Tarkan (unsurprisingly), Ayşegül Aldinç (surprisingly) and Laço Tayfa. No rock at all. But for curious non-Turkish readers living near a music shop with a good international section, I'd recommend the following:
Şebnem Ferah: Kelimeler Yetse ...
Özlem Tekin: Kime Ne or Tek Başıma (definitely not Öz, which is the boring electropop album)
Nazan Öncel: Sokak Kızı
Pentagram: Anatolia (if you don't mind early Metallica ;-))
... and for golden oldies, anything by Erkin Koray, Cem Karaca or Bulutsuzluk Özlemi, though you probably have to speak Turkish to appreciate those. If you're really lucky, you might find some Erdal Kızılçay, though he's not easy to find even in Turkey. The similarity to middle-period David Bowie (Low/Heroes) is not accidental - apparently they worked together.
Anyway, this prompted me to dig out all my Turkish rock CDs, and I'm working through them. At the moment, I'm listening to Destan, which is very much folk-rock. There are some very good songs on the album, but the group never went anywhere, partly because of splits in the band, but partly, I suspect, because if half the songs on an album are credited to "anonymous", you get stuck in the folk-rock rut. In a country like Turkey which still has a very strong folk tradition, there isn't a lot of room for folk-rockers (as opposed to folk musicians who play modern instruments). Af (whose album is also lying in the pile on my sofa) were a hard rock group with a small but loyal following who experimented with folk motifs. At the time they said if was a gamble - they'd lose their hardcore fans and weren't sure if the folky elements would get them a new fanbase. As far as I can see, it didn't.
That's not to say you can't combine folk and rock elements (look at Thin Lizzy!) but, especially in a country like Turkey, you have to be very clear abouth whether you're a rock group using the traditional instruments on a few tracks or doing the occasional folk song (e.g. Pentagram) or a folk group with a bit of distorted guitar. A fifty-fifty mix doesn't seem to work.
Browsing through Amazon's Turkish music section, it's nearly all folk and Sufi music - the only popular artists to make it into the first seven pages are Tarkan (unsurprisingly), Ayşegül Aldinç (surprisingly) and Laço Tayfa. No rock at all. But for curious non-Turkish readers living near a music shop with a good international section, I'd recommend the following:
Şebnem Ferah: Kelimeler Yetse ...
Özlem Tekin: Kime Ne or Tek Başıma (definitely not Öz, which is the boring electropop album)
Nazan Öncel: Sokak Kızı
Pentagram: Anatolia (if you don't mind early Metallica ;-))
... and for golden oldies, anything by Erkin Koray, Cem Karaca or Bulutsuzluk Özlemi, though you probably have to speak Turkish to appreciate those. If you're really lucky, you might find some Erdal Kızılçay, though he's not easy to find even in Turkey. The similarity to middle-period David Bowie (Low/Heroes) is not accidental - apparently they worked together.